Scarlett Johansson and other prominent public figures have voiced strong opinions about an Israeli AI author’s effort to fight Kanye West’s racist comments with non-consensual star deepfakes.
Last year, Kanye West engaged in yet another neo-Nazi rut and published a lot of racist material on X. A consistently bizarre TV ad for his website clothing store was shown during the Super Bowl in Los Angeles. All the items from the business except for one, a t-shirt emblazoned with a symbol, were taken out immediately after the advertising dropped.
In response, pro-Israel designer Ori Bejerano created and released an AI-generated film featuring fake versions of Israeli artists, including Johansson, Woody Allen, and actually OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, all wearing white t-shirts mimicking the style of Ye’s$ 20 shirt—only these featured the Star of David giving one-finger chants to the singer.
However, this action sparked discussion: The false versions of the people depicted in the video were created without the permission of the portrayed stars. And this is where some drew a line—with Johansson, as usual, in the anti-deepfake before.
I am a Jewish girl who doesn’t tolerate racism or love statement of any kind, she told , but I also strongly believe that the potential for love conversation multiplied by A. I. is a much greater risk than any one person who takes responsibility for it.
Mack Murdoc, a photographer and social ambassador for NASA, also raised the moral concerns of using AI for propaganda.
” Pushing boundaries is necessary, but there’s a line. AI-generated videos steal voices, manipulate narratives, and normalize deception”, Murdoc replied in a comment to Bejerano’s original post on Instagram.
” Fighting hate with lies makes us no better. This video, despite its good intent, violates rights, freedoms, and integrity. I can’t support this”, Murdoc said.
This wasn’t Johansson’s first AI-related battle. The actress had an argument with OpenAI over a voice assistant who had unintentionally mimicked her voice. ” When I heard the demo, I was shocked, angered and in disbelief that Mr. Altman would pursue a voice that sounded so eerily similar to mine”, she said in a statement. ” In a time where we are all grappling with deepfakes and the protection of our own likeness, our own work, our own identities, I believe there are questions that deserve absolute clarity”.
She also complained about celebrities ‘ photos appearing online in 2018 that had been Photoshopped.
Platforms like Shopify have already removed Ye’s merchandise, while advocacy groups including the Anti-Defamation League condemned his actions. And actual celebrities, including David Schwimmer and Isla Fisher, spoke out against his antisemitic content without resorting to AI-generated content.
Generally Intelligent Newsletter
A generative AI model’s voiceover for a weekly AI journey.